The latest iteration of the Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra closely mirrors the classic design of the Rolex Explorer. Featuring a sporty stainless steel case, applied indexes, and a sleek black lacquered dial, the Aqua Terra is impressive. However, matching the iconic Explorer in our Sunday Morning Showdown is a different challenge altogether.  

In this corner, we have Daan, owner of a 2005 replica Rolex Explorer (ref. 114270), defending the Explorer. Opposing him is RJ, representing the new Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra. But first, let’s revisit last week’s showdown.

Thomas and Mike compared two of the most renowned watch bracelets: the Oyster and the Jubilee. The Oyster is known for its ruggedness and efficient construction, while the Jubilee offers a more elegant feel but can become loose over time. The final tally showed a close call, with 54% of voters favoring the Oyster and 46% for the Jubilee. Let’s see if this week’s competition proves similarly close.

Daan argues that the Rolex Explorer stands out as the ultimate stainless steel sports watch. He appreciates its brushed and polished Oyster case, which strikes a balance between sporty and elegant. The iconic glossy black dial, marked with the signature 3, 6, and 9, delivers a sporty yet timeless aesthetic. Daan wore his Explorer throughout last summer without any concerns, highlighting its reliability and effortless style.

He notes that the Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra lacks the same identity. With an overwhelming selection of 130 references, ranging from 28mm to 43mm, it presents an identity crisis. While the Aqua Terra offers various dial colors and materials, including gold and diamond options, Daan feels that Rolex’s more streamlined offerings are a testament to the Explorer’s enduring strength.

Despite his reservations, Daan acknowledges the Aqua Terra’s impressive 8800 and 8900 movements, which are known for their precision. The new models are visually appealing, boasting clean designs with glossy black dials. He appreciates the enhanced comfort of the bracelet’s butterfly clasp, though he has minor critiques, such as the minute hand’s arrow design and the polished center links. 

RJ counters that the Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra was introduced in 2002, deliberately designed to offer a variety of options, much like the replica Rolex Datejust. He emphasizes the Aqua Terra’s versatility, suitable for both sports and formal occasions. The recent models showcase significant advancements, including the transition from ETA-based movements to in-house-developed calibers.

The Aqua Terra’s new bracelet features a comfort setting, allowing easy on-the-fly adjustments. The lacquered black dial, adorned with rhodium-plated accents, also reflects Omega’s attention to detail.

We are comparing Daan’s Rolex Explorer (either ref. 114270 or the current ref. 124270) with the new 38mm Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra (ref. 220.10.38.20.01.004). With a diameter of 38mm, a lug-to-lug measurement of 45.1mm, and a thickness of 12.3mm, it offers a contemporary feel, while the Rolex Explorer remains compact at 12mm thick and 44mm lug-to-lug.